The Problem with Frankenstein

SUMMARY: A discussion of the problems that Victor Frankenstein had that lead to the creation of his monster.

It is a real shame that most people have never read Mary Shelly’s book, Frankenstein. Indeed, for most people, the sum of their exposure to Frankenstein is as a cheesy, grainy, black and white movie with a monster that moans like a harpooned seal, and looks like some sort of Halloween factory reject. Shame indeed.

Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein is an allegory, beautifully and terrifyingly written, in which a scientist, Victor Frankenstein, bored with academia, gets caught up in the brilliance of his creation. The subtitle: A Modern Prometheus, provides a hint along this line. The tale stands as a stark, and terrific warning against uncontrolled scientific enquiry. But, Victor Frankenstein’s problem, is not so much the scientific inquiry, as it is bad science. Here is a short listing of his failings as a scientist:

1. No peer review. He labored in secret, hid from his father, and isolated himself from his colleagues. In other words, “he went rogue.” This is often one of the first signs a manager has that one is beginning to have problems: missing meetings, failing to return emails, working odd hours, not returning phone calls etc.

2. No beta plan. His first attempt was an 8 foot monster. How different the entire outcome would have been if he had created a 1 foot monster, instead a super human.

3. No maintenance plan. He gave the monster life, and then abandoned the project. The monster was born super sized, and yet he was an infant. Victor Frankenstein had made no plan for raising and for educating the monster. The entire tragedy set into play because the monster was rejected in his attempts at friendship, and he had not the emotional maturity to handle the rejection.

4. No contingency plan. He creates an 8 foot monster, and has no plan to deal with the monster should anything go wrong – dude, talk about poor planning!

5. No remediation plan. Ok, so the first monster is a failure. But does this mean you throw away two years of research. The project itself has a number of successes.

So, Victor Frankenstein’s problem is that he isolated himself from the scientific community, believing that he and he alone could understand and could control his research. At the same time, he failed to follow any sort of project management technology.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s